SOMETHING IV'E JUST REALIZED THAT IS VERY CRUCIAL (READ THIS ONLY IF YOU'VE AT LEAST READ THROUGH THE END OF THE POWER OF THREE)

HOLLYLEAF
Y'KNOW HOW SHE WAS CAUGHT IN THE CAVE-IN AT THE TUNNELS? AND SHE DIED?
WELL, I THINK NOT!

Exhibit A- she's never appearing in StarClan, OR the Dark Forest!
Exhibit B- Jay and Lion only assumed she was dead.
Exhibit C- there IS no Exhibit C! OH, THE HUMANITY!

HOW DO YOU LIKE DEM APPLES?!

PLEASE REPLY WITH YOUR BELIEFS!

I do believe she is alive. I went to this site that is directly linked to the books, a warriors wiki, I believe. They list the status for every cat, either deceased, living, or unknown. They listed Hollyleaf as unknown. I believe that she is not truly dead because it is obvious that the authors are hiding something important. It's all a part of their grand plot, I think. It was never truly proven that she died. No one found her body under the rocks.

I THINK that she'll come back from the dead. In a way. ANd then they'll go OH! NEITHER OF WHATSISFACE'S KITS HAVE POWERS. OOPS.

I don't believe she's dead. I think that she'll lose her memory or something and go do something with Sol. BECAUSE in the book it said she wasn't as opposed to Sol as her brothers.

lol Naru.
@ Amber: EXACTLY WHAT I THINK!!!
@Wolvine: ....but that's what I'm saying, maybe she was never dead....YOU can't even say if she was killed or not. Nobody went in to find her body, did they? And besides, it's much more dramatic to have everyone think Holly's dead and then when she shows up one day and has like, discovered something or something that would make the series take a significant turn for the worse or the better. And then everyone's like HOLY SHANIZZLE I THOUGHT YOU WERE DEAD YOU HOMICIDAL FREAK--I MEAN HOLLYLEAF! WELCOME BACK!

XD Lawl. What a nice welcome.

I think she's dead because, well, why do they have to show her in StarClan or the Dark Forest? It's not like Jayfeather actually took the time to find her, and no cat thought to introduce her. The same with the Dark Forest.

And, they didn't find her body because, well, no one cared, and I don't even remember Jay and Lion telling them she died because they didn't want anyone to remember her by her killing her self. I think they just said she ran off.

I've read a question that a person asked Erin Hunter regarding this and she said something like: 'I'm not saying. I suppose you'll have to wait to find out.' She'll probably come back.

That's what I was talking about.

Psh. She better be dead.

Yep, Amber. They listed her as "Status Unknown" here: http://warriors.wikia.com/wiki/Hollyleaf

... but I still have no idea because I'm nearly there. XD Personally, I couldn't care less if she's dead or not, I don't like her. =P

Here are my theories...

A) She dead fools...
B) Not dead. Returns to Thunderclan. "OMG HOLLYLEAF!! YOU CRAZY MURDERING PIECE OF FLUFF! YOURE BACK! YAY!!!"
C) Same as Naru

She should be dead. She killed poor Ashy D=

I don't like Ashfur. ><
At all.

But I HATE Hollyleaf even more.
Like really, those two are my least favorite characters.

Hollyleaf was one of my least favorite cats, but i must not be partial

I dislike Holly, Squirrel and Bramble. Their story was so predictable
-.-

I'm with Riber on this one. Hollyleaf better be dead.

I think she's not dead, but I'd like her to be.

Wolvine wrote:I dislike Holly, Squirrel and Bramble. Their story was so predictable
-.-

Aw, I love Bramble and Squirrel!

The New Prophecy was deffinatly me least favourite. Squirrel annoyed me -.-

New Prophecie was an epic fail

I didn't like the second and third series AT ALL. x.X I found it predictable, kind of boring, and worst of all, my second favorite evil cat (Hawkfrost) dies and Feathertail died. D< I hated the third series even more because I never did like the Power of Three idea. I miss the old forest so much, with its normal cats. Now the books are getting too magical. Hardly anything follows logic anymore. Half of the series was boring, and I just couldn't read Sunrise. B-O-R-I-N-G. Nothing happens except for the fact that a frinkin' innocent she-cat that did not need to die died! That made me so angry and upset with Erin Hunter... But with OOTS, I found the first book boring. But I saw great improvement in the series in book two, and I hope the three keeps fixing it.

the first in OOTS was ok, ill take your word for the third

The second. X3

If Hollyleaf was dead, they would have told us and not left it open. That would be the worst hook ever if we thought she wasn't dead but she really was all this time. She's alive, and we'll see her eventually.